Both Equally the aluminum and paper are shielded by a layer of BPA-free of charge plastic movie to shield the integrity from the bottle) For a new bottle or carton, single use, or shorter use packaging of any sort tends to not conquer reusable bottles over lengthier recurring use lifecycles https://sites.google.com/view/gabletoppak/eco-friendlypackaging-solutions-in-the-beverage-industry-sustainable-pack